AskUI vs Airtest: A Comparison

The image features a split design with a maroon background on the left, displaying the text "Academy" in a small capsule-shaped badge at the top, followed by "AskUI vs Airtest: A Comparison" in bold white letters. The right side of the image is pale blue with a soft curved edge where the two colors meet, creating a visually appealing contrast. On the right side the AskUI logo and the Airtest logo are shown.

AskUI vs Airtest: A Comparison

Let us compare AskUI and Airtest and see which one suits your use case.

AskUI

AskUI sets itself apart through its innovative use of AI-driven visual technology. This approach allows AskUI to interact with applications across a wide range of platforms – desktop, web, or even canvas-based environments – by visually understanding and responding to the user interface, much like a human would. AskUI's reliance on visual cues, rather than traditional and often fragile element selectors, makes it remarkably adaptable to changes in the user interface.

A standout feature of AskUI is its Prompt-to-Action (PTA) capability, enabling users to define automation tasks using natural language. This eliminates the need for writing complex code, allowing users to simply instruct AskUI on what needs to be done using everyday language. AskUI then translates these instructions into executable actions, making automation accessible even to those without coding experience. Additionally, AskUI offers pre-trained AI models, like PTA and UIDT, which can be customized with user data to fine-tune automation for specific needs.

AskUI boasts flexibility when it comes to operating systems, running smoothly on MacOS, Windows, and Linux. It also offers a variety of deployment options, including local, cloud-based, or hybrid environments. Integration with tools like Zapier, n8n, Docker, and Jenkins further enhances AskUI's adaptability, allowing it to fit seamlessly into diverse workflows.

Airtest

Airtest positions itself as a solution for testing games and applications, leveraging image recognition and UI hierarchy to power its automation framework. It boasts support for a wide range of game engines and applications, along with multi-platform capabilities, and an easy-to-use scripting language for interactions.

Airtest is particularly well-suited for game testing, offering features like one-click script recording and playback for Unity games, along with comprehensive reporting capabilities. Beyond games, Airtest extends its functionality to Android and Windows applications, allowing developers to write code once and run it across different platforms.  For testing Android native apps, Airtest boasts a plug-and-play approach. Additionally, when combined with Poco, a UI inspection framework, Airtest can access and interact with iOS native elements, facilitating iOS testing as well.

Airtest also offers a Selenium Plugin, based on the Chrome DevTools Protocol, allowing users to record and generate Selenium scripts for web applications, ensuring accurate access to web elements.  Airtest IDE, a cross-platform UI automation IDE, simplifies the process of creating and running Airtest scripts. The IDE is available for download across different platforms including Windows, macOS, and Ubuntu.

Comparing the Contenders: AskUI vs. Airtest

Feature AskUI Airtest
Target Applications Cross-platform: desktop, web, and canvas-based Primarily focused on game testing; also supports Android, iOS, and Windows applications, as well as web applications with Selenium plugin
Core Technology AI-powered visual recognition and natural language processing Image recognition and UI hierarchy analysis
User Interaction Prompt-to-Action (PTA) using natural language instructions Scripting language based on Python, image recognition for element interaction
Deployment Flexible options: local, cloud, and hybrid Airtest IDE provides a platform for script creation and execution, with support for different operating systems.
Key Focus Making UI automation accessible to users of all skill levels using AI-powered visual recognition and natural language processing Simplifying game and application testing through image recognition and UI hierarchy analysis, with a focus on ease of use and multi-platform support.

What Makes AskUI Unique?

  • Visual UI Recognition: AskUI's ability to "see" the user interface like a human user makes it remarkably resilient to changes in the UI. It can automate a broader range of applications, including those with dynamic or complex interfaces that might pose challenges for traditional automation tools.
  • Natural Language Automation: The Prompt-to-Action feature is a game-changer, democratizing automation by making it accessible to individuals without coding expertise. Users can articulate tasks in plain English, which AskUI seamlessly translates into automated actions.
·
On this page